Watercolour-style illustration of Brisbane's industrial riverfront at sunset, featuring a container port, cargo ship, freight rail corridor, warehouses, road infrastructure and the Brisbane skyline beyond the Story Bridge. The scene highlights trade, investment, transport networks and the movement of goods that support economic productivity and growth.

How Competition and Investment Shape Productivity in Australia

Part 4 of the Australia’s Productivity Puzzle series

If productivity is the key to rising living standards, why has Australia’s productivity growth slowed?

One common explanation points to technology. Another focuses on education and skills. Others emphasise regulation, demographics or global economic conditions.

All of these factors matter.

But there is another explanation receiving increasing attention from economists: Australia’s economy may have become less effective at directing labour and capital towards the firms that can use them most productively.1,2

This might sound like an abstract problem. In reality, it sits at the centre of economic prosperity.

The issue is not whether Australians are working hard. The issue is whether workers, businesses and investors are operating in an environment that rewards innovation, investment and efficiency.

To understand why this matters, we first need to understand how productivity grows across an economy.

Productivity Is About More Than Individual Businesses

Not all businesses are equally productive.

Some adopt new technologies quickly.

Some develop better products.

Some discover more efficient ways to organise production.

Others struggle to keep pace.

This variation exists in every industry. Even businesses operating side-by-side in the same market can produce dramatically different levels of output using similar resources.2

At first glance, this may not seem important.

However, economy-wide productivity growth depends not only on individual businesses becoming more efficient, but also on resources shifting toward the most productive firms.

Efficient firms should be able to expand.

Less productive firms should face pressure to improve.

When this process works effectively, overall productivity rises.

In many ways, productivity growth is a story about economic evolution.

Successful firms grow. Less efficient firms adapt or lose market share. Resources flow towards better uses.

The more effectively this occurs, the more productive the economy becomes.

Why Competition Matters

Competition plays a critical role in this process.

Competitive pressure encourages businesses to innovate, invest and improve efficiency.

Businesses that fail to keep pace risk losing customers to competitors.

Businesses that innovate successfully can grow and expand.

In competitive markets, productivity improvements are rewarded.

Consumers also benefit. Competition tends to encourage lower prices, higher quality and greater choice.

Importantly, competition helps determine where resources go.

Investors are more likely to support firms that generate strong returns.

Workers often move towards businesses that offer better opportunities and higher wages.

Capital and labour gradually shift toward the most productive parts of the economy.

This process is one of the most important drivers of long-run productivity growth.1

When Competition Weakens

The reverse can also occur.

If competition becomes weaker, productive firms can find it harder to expand while less productive firms face less pressure to improve.

Recent Australian research suggests this may have become part of the productivity story.

Jonathan Hambur found that rising market power and increasing business mark-ups may have contributed to slower productivity growth by reducing the flow of labour towards highly productive firms.3

This does not necessarily mean firms are acting improperly.

Rather, it suggests the economy may have become less dynamic.

Barriers to entry can rise.

Competitive pressure can weaken.

Established firms can become more insulated from challengers.

When that occurs, the process of productivity-enhancing reallocation becomes less effective.

The result is slower productivity growth across the broader economy.

The Problem of Misallocation

Economists use the term misallocation to describe a situation where labour and capital are not flowing to their most productive uses.2

Imagine two firms.

The first firm invests successfully in technology, training and innovation. Output per worker rises and the business generates strong returns.

The second firm invests poorly and produces less output for the same resources.

In an efficient economy, labour and capital would gradually move toward the first firm.

However, if barriers prevent that movement, resources can remain locked in less productive uses.

This matters because productivity depends not only on how well individual firms perform, but also on where economic resources are located.

Research by Andrews, et. al., suggests that weaker resource allocation and reduced investment have played an important role in Australia’s productivity slowdown.2

Their findings indicate that capital has become less responsive to differences in business performance than in previous decades.

In other words, productive firms may not be attracting investment as efficiently as they once did.

Investment Matters Too

Investment is another essential ingredient of productivity growth.

Workers become more productive when they have access to better machinery, software, equipment and infrastructure.

Businesses become more productive when they adopt new technologies and expand productive capacity.

However, investment has slowed in many advanced economies over recent decades, including Australia.2

This creates a feedback loop.

Lower investment slows productivity growth.

Slower productivity growth weakens growth opportunities.

Weaker opportunities reduce incentives to invest.

Breaking this cycle is one of the major challenges facing policymakers and businesses alike.

Why This Matters for Living Standards

The consequences extend far beyond business performance.

When productivity growth slows:

  • Wage growth tends to weaken.
  • Living standards rise more slowly.
  • Governments collect less additional revenue from a growing economy.
  • Future generations inherit fewer opportunities for rising prosperity.

This links directly back to the central puzzle we explored in the first article.

Australia’s economy continues to grow.

Yet improvements in living standards have become more difficult to achieve.

Part of the explanation may be that the economy has become less effective at directing labour and capital toward their most productive uses.

Looking Ahead

Technology often dominates discussions about productivity.

Artificial intelligence, automation and digital transformation are frequently presented as solutions to Australia’s productivity challenge.

These developments may indeed play an important role.

However, technology alone is not enough.

Productivity gains only emerge when businesses adopt new technologies, invest effectively and operate within competitive markets that reward innovation and efficiency.

In the final article of this series, we’ll examine whether artificial intelligence can help restart productivity growth, and what history tells us about the conditions required for a technological revolution to improve living standards.


Endnotes

  1. Productivity Commission. (2023). Advancing Prosperity. Commonwealth of Australia. Advancing Prosperity – 5 year Productivity inquiry report | Productivity Commission ↩︎
  2. Andrews, D., Hambur, J., Hansell, D., & Wheeler, A. (2023). Doing Less, with Less: Capital Misallocation, Investment and the Productivity Slowdown in Australia (RDP 2023-03). Reserve Bank of Australia. RDP 2023-03: Doing Less, with Less: Capital Misallocation, Investment and the Productivity Slowdown in Australia | RBA ↩︎
  3. Hambur, J. (2023). Product market competition and its implications for the Australian economy. Economic Record, 99(324), 32-57. https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-4932.12707 ↩︎

Making economics make sense. Subscribe for clear, practical insights.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *